Soccer Player of the Year
| Name | School | Season |
|---|---|---|
 Raymond Mukailov | Lexington | 2016-17 |
 Ahmed Mahmoud | Rochester | 2016-17 |
 Raymond Mukailov | Lexington | 2015-16 |
 Raymond Mukhailov | Lexington | 2014-15 |
 Ahmad Mahoud | Rochester | 2014-15 |
 Tim Artinian | Rochester | 2013-14 |
| Tim Artinian | Rochester | 2012-13 |
 Ken Gentzke | Rochester | 2011-12 |
 Angel Ortiz | Marie Philip | 2010-11 |
 Benjamin Letendre | Marie Philip | 2009-10 |
 Michael Lumley | St. Mary’s | 2008-09 |
 Shaquana McDonough | Marie Philip | 2008-09 |
| Richard Spiecker | Rochester | 2007-08 |
 Dale Powell | New York | 2007-08 |
8 Man Soccer Player of the Year
| Name | School | Season |
|---|---|---|
 Bode Aggas | Rochester | 2019-20 |
 Thomas Coates | Rochester | 2018-19 |
 Levi Ruper | Western Pennsylvania | 2017-18 |
| Dimas Cruz | Rhode Island | - |
11 Man Soccer Player of the Year
| Name | School | Season |
|---|---|---|
 Devor Bauman | Ohio | 2019-20 |
 Chad D’Amore | Western Pennsylvania | 2018-19 |
 Dylan Christoffels | Pennsylvania | 2017-18 |
| Christopher Jiminez | Marie Philips and Walden school | - |
